James Charles

James makes technically solid content but the constant controversy around his actions makes it hard to feel good supporting him. His influence is huge but so is the pattern of inappropriate behavior and inadequate responses. Moved on to other creators.

His makeup skills are undeniably good, but the scandals and problematic behavior keep piling up. Even when he addresses issues, it feels like damage control rather than genuine accountability. Hard to support someone with this pattern.

James has serious credibility issues after multiple controversies that he's handled poorly

His apologies feel performative and the community trust he damaged hasn't really recovered. I can't recommend someone with that track record.